Wrongful Death of a Child in New York

What Can Parents Recover in a New York Wrongful Death Case?

Less than almost anywhere else in the country, and it is important that a family hears that from a lawyer rather than discovering it later.

New York limits wrongful death damages to pecuniary loss. EPTL § 5-4.3 permits fair and just compensation for the pecuniary injuries resulting from the death, and New York courts have read that to exclude grief, sorrow, and the loss of a child's love and companionship.

Applied to a child, a rule written around economic contribution produces a number that has nothing to do with what was lost.

There is a second claim, held by the estate rather than by the parents, and in a child's case it is usually where the value of the case actually sits.

Call (888) 713-6653 when you are ready. There is no fee unless we win.

Why the Pecuniary Loss Rule Falls Hardest on a Child's Death

New York's wrongful death statute dates to the nineteenth century and was written around a straightforward premise: a family that lost a wage earner lost income, and the law would replace it.

That premise does not describe a child. A child is not supporting anyone, and the pecuniary framework has no vocabulary for what a family actually lost.^[1]

What remains recoverable in the wrongful death claim itself is narrow.

• Loss of the child's services. The value of household and family services the child provided and would have provided, which for an older child with responsibilities at home is real and for a young child is largely theoretical.
• Loss of future support. Reasonably expected financial contribution to the parents, which is speculative for a child and correspondingly difficult to establish.
• Medical expenses. Care provided before the death.
• Funeral and burial expenses. Recoverable and documented.
• Interest from the date of death. Which is not a small component in a case that takes years.

What is not recoverable, and this is where the rule does its damage: the parents' grief, their mental anguish, the loss of the child's society and companionship, and the loss of the relationship itself. New York has stood alone among nearly all states on this for decades.

The Survival Claim: Where a Child's Case Usually Carries Its Value

There are two lawsuits after a death in New York, and families are almost never told about the second one.

The wrongful death claim belongs to the distributees and compensates their pecuniary loss. The survival claim belongs to the estate and compensates what the child themselves experienced between the injury and death: conscious pain and suffering, and the fear and awareness of impending death where the evidence supports it.^[2]

In a child's death that distinction reorganizes the entire case. The wrongful death claim is constrained by a rule written for wage earners. The survival claim is not constrained by that rule at all, and New York places no cap on it.

What the survival claim requires is evidence of consciousness during the interval, and that evidence comes from records generated by other people in the hours around the death: paramedic run sheets, the first nursing notes, Glasgow Coma Scale scores, and emergency department documentation. Our page on survival actions and conscious pain and suffering covers how that interval is established.

Where the death was instantaneous, the survival claim is limited or unavailable, and a family should be told that plainly rather than left to discover it during litigation.

Before Anything Else, an Estate Has to Exist

No wrongful death case in New York can be filed until Surrogate's Court appoints a personal representative of the estate, and families almost never know that.

The claim belongs to the estate, and only the appointed representative has the authority to bring it. That is a capacity requirement rather than a deadline, but it consumes time, and it sits in front of everything else.

What the Appointment Involves

A petition in the Surrogate's Court for the county where the child resided, notice to the persons entitled to it, and letters issued by the court. For a child who died without a will, which is nearly always the case, the parents are ordinarily the distributees and one of them is typically appointed.

We can help get the estate opened as part of taking on a wrongful death matter, so a family is not left to work out that step alone while they are grieving.

Why It Interacts With the Deadlines

The wrongful death action must be commenced within two years after the death under EPTL § 5-4.1. Where the defendant is a public entity, a hospital operated by a public corporation, a school district, a municipality, the notice of claim runs from the appointment of the estate representative rather than from the death, which is a rule that helps families and that almost nobody knows exists.

It helps only if somebody applies. A family that has not opened an estate has not started that clock and has not preserved anything.

The Circumstances That Produce These Cases

Child death cases in New York arise from a recognizable set of failures, and each carries its own defendants and its own evidence.

• Birth injury and delivery failures. Oxygen deprivation, delayed cesarean, and neonatal management, with their own compressed deadlines under the infancy rules.
• Pediatric misdiagnosis. Sepsis, meningitis, appendicitis, and diabetic ketoacidosis, where the window for treatment closed while a child was sent home.
• Motor vehicle collisions. Including a child struck as a pedestrian or carried as a passenger.
• Window falls and premises failures. Where a required guard or barrier was absent. Our page on window guard requirements and child window falls covers the New York City rule.
• Drownings. Pools, beaches, and camps, where supervision and barrier requirements were not met.
• Defective products. Furniture tip-overs, sleep products, button batteries, and recalled equipment.
• School, camp, and childcare supervision. Which frequently involves a public entity and a 90-day notice requirement.
• Lithium-ion battery and residential fires. Where a landlord or a manufacturer is answerable.

Where a public entity is involved, everything compresses. Where a criminal prosecution is running alongside, the civil case does not have to wait for it, and the civil case reaches defendants a criminal court never touches.

What the Two Claims Together Can Recover

New York places no cap on compensatory damages, and the constraint in a child's case is the pecuniary rule rather than a dollar limit.

• Conscious pain and suffering. Through the survival claim, for the interval between injury and death, including the awareness of what was happening.
• Medical expenses. Emergency, surgical, and intensive care provided before the death.
• Funeral and burial expenses. Documented and recoverable.
• Loss of the child's services. Past and prospective, established from what the child actually did and would have done.
• Loss of reasonably expected support. Where the evidence supports a projection.
• Interest from the date of death. On the wrongful death award.
• Punitive damages. Where the conduct was sufficiently reckless, which arises in impaired driving and in some product cases.

A settlement is allocated between the wrongful death and survival claims, and that allocation is approved by the court. It matters, because the two claims have different beneficiaries and different tax treatment, and getting it right is part of the work rather than a formality at the end.

 

No Family Should Learn the Pecuniary Loss Rule From a Settlement Letter

A family that has lost a child should not have to learn New York's pecuniary loss rule from a settlement letter.

• The lawyer other lawyers call. Don Worley built that reputation representing high-impact, high-stakes cases for the seriously injured and surviving family.
• An honest account of the law at the first conversation. Including what New York does not allow, so nothing arrives as a surprise later.
• Help getting the estate opened. So the appointment that has to come first is not one more thing a grieving family is left to work out alone.
• Both claims developed, including the one families are never told about. The survival claim is frequently where a child's case carries its value, and it is proved from records generated in the first hours.
• Every deadline fixed early. The two year period, the notice of claim where a public entity is involved, and the appointment that starts it.
• Built for a courtroom, resolved at a table. Most cases settle. They settle for more when the other side believes the alternative is real.
• The numbers behind the promise. More than $100 million recovered across 40,000 handled cases, at a 98 percent recovery rate. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes, and every claim turns on its own facts.