Florida's Serious Injury Threshold Explained

Free Case Evaluation


Let's See If You Have a Case...

Please select what happened...
Were you injured / hurt?
What is the primary type of injury?
Were you hospitalized or receive medical treatment?
Were you at fault for the accident?
When did the accident happen?
Where did the accident happen?
Was the other driver driving a commercial vehicle?
Please share how best to contact you?

Pain and Suffering After a Florida Crash Takes One of Four Injuries

Florida's serious injury threshold decides whether you can recover money for pain and suffering from the driver who hit you.

Under § 627.737(2) of the Florida Statutes, you can recover it only if your injury is permanent, leaves significant and permanent scarring or disfigurement, causes a significant and permanent loss of an important bodily function, or is fatal.

If your injury does not qualify, you can still recover the medical bills and lost income your PIP did not pay.

Florida serious injury threshold attorney

The threshold bars pain and suffering and the other non-economic damages, and nothing else.

Whether an injury is permanent is a medical question, and the at-fault driver's insurance company can hire its own doctor to dispute it.

Your side of that question is your treating doctor's opinion and the test results behind it.

The deadline to file a lawsuit is two years for a crash after March 24, 2023 (four years for one on or before that date), and it does not wait for that opinion.


At-a-Glance: The Serious Injury Threshold

  • Fla. Stat. § 627.737(2) limits pain and suffering claims against an at-fault driver to four kinds of injury
  • Permanent injury, significant and permanent scarring, significant and permanent loss of an important bodily function, or death
  • A doctor must call the injury permanent within a reasonable degree of medical probability
  • Below the threshold you can still recover the medical bills and lost income PIP did not pay
  • The same threshold applies to a pain and suffering claim on your own uninsured motorist coverage
Florida crash injury lawsuit threshold


The Four Ways an Injury Meets Florida's Threshold

Section 627.737(2) lists four kinds of injury, and yours needs to fit only one.[1]


1. Permanent Injury Within a Reasonable Degree of Medical Probability

A herniated disc with lasting symptoms, a joint that will not regain full motion, chronic pain traced to the crash, and a brain injury with lasting deficits are examples. The phrase "reasonable degree of medical probability" means a physician has to say that the injury is permanent and that the crash caused it, so this category rests on what your doctor writes and will testify to.


2. Significant and Permanent Scarring or Disfigurement

Cuts from glass, road rash, burns, and surgical scars from crash-related operations can qualify when the scarring is both significant and permanent. A scar's size, location, and visibility over time are the evidence, so take dated photographs through the whole healing period and keep them.


3. Significant and Permanent Loss of an Important Bodily Function

Examples are lost grip strength in a working hand, a knee that can no longer manage stairs, hearing loss, and bowel or bladder dysfunction. The loss has to be significant and permanent, and the function has to be an important one. Records that show what you can no longer do at work and at home support this category.


4. Death

A fatal crash meets the threshold. The family's claim is brought under Florida's Wrongful Death Act, which has its own rules on who recovers and what they recover.

proving permanent injury Florida crash

How Permanence Gets Proven, and How Insurers Fight It

You meet the threshold with medical evidence, and three things carry it.

Your treating physician's permanency opinion. The doctor who managed your care states, within a reasonable degree of medical probability, that the injury is permanent. It is the opinion the statute's wording calls for, and it may come with an impairment rating. Your doctor may not be able to give it until your recovery has leveled off, and the lawsuit deadline keeps running in the meantime.

Objective findings behind the opinion. MRI results, range-of-motion measurements, nerve studies, and surgical reports give the opinion something to rest on. A herniation that shows on imaging with matching symptoms is harder for an insurance company to dispute than a report of pain alone.

Consistent treatment without gaps. The insurance company will read the dates in your chart, and a three-month gap in care will be argued as proof that the injury resolved. Keep your appointments, and tell the provider at each one what still hurts and what you still cannot do.

The insurance company's answer is the compulsory medical exam, an evaluation by a doctor it selects and pays. That doctor's report may say your injury is not permanent. Your lawyer can question that doctor under oath about the exam and what it did and did not test.

The threshold fight is usually over before the lawsuit starts. It gets decided in treatment records written months earlier, documenting the severity of your condition. The fight is whether the insurance company has any room to pretend the injury is not permanent.


What You Can Recover If Your Crash Injury Is Not Permanent

The threshold limits one category of damages and leaves the rest of your claim in place.

Below the threshold, you can still recover from the at-fault driver the economic losses PIP left unpaid: the 20 percent of medical bills PIP did not cover, the 40 percent of lost wages, and everything beyond the $10,000 limit. What you cannot recover is money for pain, suffering, mental anguish, and inconvenience.

Above the threshold, you can claim pain and suffering, mental anguish, and loss of enjoyment of life along with every economic loss. Florida places no cap on those damages in a claim against a private defendant, as our Florida damage caps page explains.

The threshold protects a driver whose vehicle carried the no-fault insurance Florida requires, and it does not apply to a taxicab. It does apply to a pain and suffering claim on your own uninsured motorist coverage, which may be your only source of payment because Florida does not require most drivers to carry bodily injury liability coverage.

Your own share of fault matters too. In a lawsuit filed after March 24, 2023, a person a judge or jury finds more than 50 percent at fault recovers nothing, and a smaller share reduces the award in proportion, as our page on Florida's comparative negligence rule explains.

 

Herniated Discs, Fractures, and Whiplash Under Florida's Serious Injury Threshold

No diagnosis qualifies automatically, because the statute asks about permanence and a doctor has to supply it. Injuries that can meet the threshold when a physician documents permanence include herniated and bulging discs with radiculopathy, fractures repaired with surgical hardware, torn rotator cuffs and knee ligaments that leave lasting limitation, traumatic brain injuries with lasting cognitive symptoms, complex regional pain syndrome and other chronic nerve pain, and any injury that leaves significant and permanent scarring.

Whiplash, strains, and sprains are harder to prove because they often show nothing on imaging. They can still qualify. What the statute requires is a physician's opinion that the injury is permanent, and measured limitations and a steady record of care give that opinion support. If you have a soft-tissue injury that has not healed, ask your doctor what testing would document it.


Serious Injury Threshold Questions After a Crash

What is the serious injury threshold in Florida?

It is the rule in Fla. Stat. § 627.737(2) that limits when a person hurt in a crash can recover pain and suffering from the at-fault driver. The injury must be a permanent injury within a reasonable degree of medical probability, significant and permanent scarring or disfigurement, a significant and permanent loss of an important bodily function, or death. The rule does not stop you from suing for the medical bills and lost income PIP did not pay.

What counts as a permanent injury after a Florida car accident?

An injury that a physician ties to the crash and describes as permanent within a reasonable degree of medical probability. Herniated discs with ongoing symptoms, surgically repaired fractures, joint injuries with lasting limitation, brain injuries with lasting deficits, and chronic pain conditions can all qualify. Test results and an impairment rating from your treating physician support the opinion.

Can I recover anything if my injury does not meet the threshold?

Yes. The threshold bars pain and suffering and the other non-economic damages. You can still recover from the at-fault driver the economic losses PIP left unpaid: the 20 percent of medical bills PIP did not cover, the 40 percent of lost wages, and everything above the $10,000 PIP limit.

Does whiplash meet Florida's serious injury threshold?

It can. A soft-tissue injury qualifies when a physician gives the opinion that it is permanent, and that opinion is stronger with imaging or measured limitations behind it. Sparse treatment records and long gaps in care give the insurance company its argument that the injury healed, so keep treating and keep reporting your symptoms.

Who decides whether my injury meets the threshold?

A jury, if the case is tried. Before that, your treating doctors and the doctor hired by the insurance company give opposing opinions, and settlement talks follow the strength of each. A permanency opinion from your treating physician, supported by test results, is the evidence the insurance company has to answer.

How long do I have to file a lawsuit if my injury may be permanent?

If the crash happened after March 24, 2023, you have two years from that date to file. A crash on or before March 24, 2023 keeps the older four-year deadline (Fla. Stat. § 95.11(5)(a)). The deadline does not pause while you wait for a permanency opinion, so talk to a Florida car accident attorney while you are still treating.

Ask Whether Your Injury Qualifies Under § 627.737 While You Are Still Treating

Months into treatment, you may still not know whether your injury counts as permanent or what your claim is worth either way.

Lawsuit Legal will tell you plainly what you can recover if the injury is not permanent and what your claim adds if your doctor says it is.

The review is free, we are paid only if we recover money for you, and we advance the costs of the case. Call (888) 713-6653 while there is still time to get a permanency opinion before the filing deadline.

 

 

 

 

 

Free Case Evaluation


Let's See If You Have a Case...

Please select what happened?
Were you injured / hurt?
What is the primary type of injury?
Were you hospitalized or receive medical treatment?
Were you at fault for the accident?
When did the accident happen?
Where did the accident happen?
Was the other driver driving a commercial vehicle?
Please share how best to contact you
External Resources
Legal Representation

"Speak with our Florida accident attorneys for a free, confidential review of your potential claim. Past results vary based on the unique facts of each case."

Find out more >>