Free Case Evaluation
Let's See If You Have a Case...
More Than 50 Percent at Fault Ends a Florida Injury Claim
Florida divides fault for an injury into percentages, and your compensation is reduced by your share.
If a judge or jury finds you more than 50 percent at fault, you recover nothing.
At exactly 50 percent you still recover half of your damages, and at any share above 50 you recover none.
The rule is in section 768.81 of the Florida Statutes, and the bar applies to negligence lawsuits filed after March 24, 2023.
Medical malpractice claims are exempt, so a patient's share of fault reduces the award there and never erases it.
An insurance company adjuster will put a percentage on you long before any jury does, and that number is a negotiating position that binds no one.
At-a-Glance: Florida Comparative Fault
- Your recovery is reduced by your percentage of fault (Fla. Stat. § 768.81(2))
- Anyone found more than 50 percent at fault recovers nothing (§ 768.81(6), added by HB 837)
- The bar applies to lawsuits filed after March 24, 2023, and only a judge or jury can impose it
- Medical malpractice claims are exempt from the bar, so fault only reduces the award
- The insurance company's early fault percentage is a negotiating position and bars nothing

What a $400,000 Claim Pays at 10, 40, and 51 Percent Fault
A judge or jury assigns each party a percentage of fault, and each person's damages are reduced by their own share.[1] The reduction applies to economic and noneconomic damages alike.
The Math at Three Fault Levels
10 percent at fault: A $400,000 award is reduced to $360,000.
40 percent at fault: The same award is reduced to $240,000. At exactly 50 percent it would be $200,000, the last point at which you recover anything.
51 percent at fault: The same award pays nothing, because any share above 50 percent bars the claim. A finding of 50.5 percent has the same result.
Each figure is the award before attorney fees, case costs, and medical liens come out. Florida adopted the bar in March 2023, and other states divide fault differently, as mapped in how each state handles shared fault.
Every point between those examples is money. On a $400,000 claim, each percentage point of fault is $4,000, which is why a conversation about fault with an insurance company adjuster is never a casual one.
Which Florida Claims Still Get Pure Comparative Negligence After HB 837
Before HB 837, Florida used pure comparative negligence, under which a person 90 percent at fault could still recover 10 percent of their damages. HB 837 ended that for lawsuits filed after March 24, 2023, and put the more-than-50-percent bar in its place.
Two groups of claims are treated differently.
Medical malpractice is exempt. The bar does not apply to injury or death claims for medical negligence, so pure comparative fault still governs them (Fla. Stat. § 768.81(6)). A patient found 60 percent at fault for skipping follow-up visits can still recover 40 percent in a malpractice case.
Injuries from before the law changed are unsettled. The 2023 rule applies to lawsuits filed after March 24, 2023. Whether it reaches an injury that happened before that date and was sued on afterward has not been settled, and Florida courts are still working through it. If your injury is that old, have a lawyer check the dates before you assume either rule. The rest of the reform is covered on our page about how HB 837 changed Florida injury law.
The deadline to file runs on a different date, the date of the injury. You have two years to file a negligence lawsuit for an injury that happened after March 24, 2023, and four years for one that happened on or before that date (Fla. Stat. § 95.11(5)(a)).[2]
Evidence That Raises and Lowers an Insurance Company's Fault Percentage
No formula produces a fault percentage. An adjuster's number comes from the evidence in the file and from what the insurance company expects a jury would do with it, and both can change.
What raises it. Adjusters build your percentage from whatever the file holds: a recorded statement in which you said "I didn't see him," a police report that noted your speed, and arguments that you were distracted, braked late, or could have avoided the crash. A traffic ticket goes into the file too. What you told the officer for the crash report cannot be used as evidence at trial (Fla. Stat. § 316.066(4)), although what the officer saw and what witnesses said can be.
What lowers it. Physical evidence answers those arguments. It includes vehicle damage patterns, event data recorder downloads, skid marks and final rest positions, camera footage from businesses and doorbells, and witnesses with no stake in the outcome. The other driver's phone records and a crash reconstruction can show what happened in the seconds before impact.
Much of that evidence does not last. Camera systems record over old footage and damaged vehicles get repaired, so the first days after a crash are when the fault record is easiest to preserve.
Shared Fault in Florida Fall, Dog Bite, and Seat Belt Claims
Section 768.81 governs negligence cases generally, product liability claims included, so the same percentage argument appears well outside car crashes.
In a slip and fall claim, the defense argues about your footwear, your phone, and where you were looking. In a crash claim, not wearing a seat belt can reduce damages through the seat belt defense. Under the dog bite statute your recovery is reduced by your share of fault, and whether the more-than-50-percent bar also applies to dog bite cases has not been settled.
When several parties share the blame, each defendant pays only its own percentage. Fault assigned to a driver with no insurance, or to someone who is not in the lawsuit, is money nobody pays.
None of this touches your own personal injury protection after a car crash. PIP pays 80 percent of your medical bills and 60 percent of your lost income, up to $10,000, even if you caused the crash, and the medical benefits require treatment within 14 days after it. From the other driver, you can claim the bills and lost income PIP left unpaid, and pain and suffering only if the injury meets the serious injury threshold.
Florida Comparative Negligence FAQ
- What is Florida's comparative negligence rule?
-
Florida uses modified comparative negligence under Fla. Stat. § 768.81. Your damages are reduced by your percentage of fault, and if you are found more than 50 percent at fault, you recover nothing. The bar applies to lawsuits filed after March 24, 2023, under HB 837, which replaced Florida's pure comparative system. Medical malpractice claims remain under the pure comparative rule.
- Can I still recover if the accident was partly my fault?
-
Yes, as long as you are found 50 percent or less at fault. At 30 percent fault, a $100,000 award is reduced to $70,000, before fees, costs, and medical liens. Until a judge or jury decides, the percentage is set by negotiation and evidence, and you do not have to accept the insurance company's first number.
- Who decides my percentage of fault in Florida?
-
A judge or jury, if the case is tried. Before that, the percentage is a negotiating position. The adjuster proposes one, your attorney answers with evidence, and the number that settles the case reflects what each side expects a jury would find. Physical evidence, camera footage, event data recorder downloads, and witness accounts are what move it.
- Does the 51% bar apply to medical malpractice in Florida?
-
No. The rule that bars anyone found more than 50 percent at fault, often called the 51 percent bar, does not apply to medical negligence claims (Fla. Stat. § 768.81(6)). Pure comparative negligence still applies in malpractice cases, so a patient found more than half at fault can still recover a proportional share of damages.
- The insurance company says the crash was mostly my fault. Is that final?
-
No. An adjuster's fault percentage binds no one, and only a finding by a judge or jury can bar a claim. It is an opening position, and it is often built from a recorded statement given without advice. You answer it with evidence, such as a crash reconstruction, camera footage, vehicle data, and witnesses.
- What should I do if the adjuster blames me for the crash?
-
Do not agree to a percentage or give a recorded statement about fault before you have seen the evidence. Ask the adjuster what the number is based on. Write down the names of witnesses, photograph the vehicles before they are repaired, and ask nearby businesses to save their camera footage. Then have a car accident attorney review the file before you answer.
Have a Lawyer Read the Fault Letter Before You Answer the Adjuster
If an insurance company has told you the crash was partly or mostly your fault, you do not have to accept its number, and you should not answer it from memory.
Lawsuit Legal reviews the evidence behind the percentage and tells you what a jury could be shown. We advance the costs of the case, a reconstruction expert's fee included when one is needed, and charge no fee unless we recover money for you.
Call (888) 713-6653 for a free consultation, and bring the letter, the crash report, and any photos you have.
Free Case Evaluation
Let's See If You Have a Case...