Free Case Evaluation
Let's See If You Have a Case...
Florida Crashes That Need a Lawyer and the Ones That Do Not
Not every Florida car accident needs a lawyer.
If nobody was hurt, or a few sore days passed after one checkup, you can usually handle the claim yourself with your own insurance company and the other driver's.
If your injury needed ongoing treatment, the answer is usually yes, for reasons specific to Florida law.
Your PIP medical benefits depend on treatment within 14 days after the crash, and they can stop at $2,500 without an emergency medical condition finding.
You can recover for pain and suffering only if the injury meets the serious injury threshold.
If a judge or jury puts more than 50 percent of the fault on you, you recover nothing.
A free consultation tells you which kind of claim you have, and you owe nothing for asking.
At-a-Glance: When a Lawyer Matters
- Usually unnecessary: property damage only, or minor soreness that resolved after one checkup
- Worth a consultation: ongoing treatment, disputed fault, or an at-fault driver with little coverage
- PIP medical benefits require treatment within 14 days and stop at $2,500 without an emergency finding
- More than 50 percent of the fault, as found by a judge or jury, bars the claim
- Contingency means no fee unless we recover money: You Win or It's Free

Three Car Accident Claims You Can Handle Without an Attorney
A lawyer adds little in three situations:
- Property damage only. Nobody was hurt, and the dispute is over repair estimates. The at-fault driver's property damage liability coverage pays, or your own collision coverage does.
- Minor soreness that fully resolved. You had a few stiff days and one checkup, and the symptoms are gone. PIP pays 80 percent of the visit, and what is left is too small for a claim against the other driver.
- Losses of a few hundred dollars. A contingency fee makes no economic sense for you on a claim that size.
One caution goes with that list. Some injuries show up late, and soreness that seemed to resolve can turn out to be a disc injury. Get checked by a qualifying provider within 14 days after the crash, because PIP pays no medical benefits if your first treatment comes later than that.[1]
Disputed Fault, Lasting Injuries, and Thin Coverage That Call for a Lawyer
Talk to a lawyer when any of these is true:
Your injury needed more than a checkup. Imaging, specialists, therapy, injections, or surgery mean your bills will pass what PIP pays, and the value of the claim then depends on proof that the injury is permanent. What that value turns on is covered on our Florida settlement value page.
Fault is disputed, even slightly. Each percentage point of fault you accept from an adjuster reduces the claim, and a judge or jury that finds you more than 50 percent at fault awards nothing.[2] Vehicle data and camera footage are how a wrong percentage gets corrected.
The at-fault driver has little or no insurance. Florida does not require most drivers to carry bodily injury liability coverage, so recovery often depends on other policies, such as your uninsured motorist coverage and whether it stacks, an employer's policy, or a vehicle owner's.
A commercial vehicle, a rideshare, or a government vehicle is involved. Commercial and rideshare claims involve layered policies. A claim against a city, county, or state agency adds a written-notice step and a waiting period before a lawsuit, and recovery is capped.
Someone died. A wrongful death claim has its own statute and its own list of survivors, and it must be filed within two years of the death. No family should have to manage that alone.
Four Florida Rules an Insurance Company Can Use Against an Unrepresented Claim
Four rules decide most Florida crash claims, and the insurance company's adjuster works with them every day.
The 14-day rule ends PIP medical benefits when the first treatment comes late, and without an emergency medical condition finding those benefits stop at $2,500. Whether you can recover for pain and suffering turns on the serious injury threshold, which is proven with a doctor's opinion that the injury is permanent.[3] If the injury is not permanent, you can still claim the medical bills and lost income PIP did not pay. On fault, anyone found more than 50 percent responsible recovers nothing, and what you say in a recorded statement in the first week can be used to argue your percentage months later.
The other driver's insurance company works for the other driver. Its adjuster knows these rules and has no reason to walk you through them.
What a Car Accident Lawyer Costs on a Contingency Fee
We work on a contingency fee. The fee is a percentage of what we recover, it is set out in a written agreement you sign before we start, and there is no fee if there is no recovery. You Win or It's Free is our line for it. The consultation is free as well.
We do not print a percentage here, because the agreement sets it, and the Rules Regulating The Florida Bar limit what a lawyer may charge in an injury case.[4] The agreement must also say which costs come out of the recovery and whether they come out before or after the fee is calculated. We advance the costs of the case, expert fees included. You are given a Statement of Client's Rights to sign, and you can cancel the agreement within three business days.
What you take home is the settlement less the fee, the case costs, and any amount owed back to a health plan that paid for your treatment. Ask any lawyer you interview to show you that arithmetic on your own numbers before you sign.
Is a Lawyer Worth the Fee on a Florida Car Accident Claim?
It depends on what the claim involves, and no lawyer can promise that you will end up with more money.
A car accident attorney earns the fee by doing work the claim needs and you would otherwise do alone. That work is getting the emergency medical condition finding into your record, documenting permanence for the serious injury threshold, contesting the fault percentage with evidence, finding every policy that applies, and filing the lawsuit on time if the insurance company will not pay what the record supports. The deadline is two years from a crash that happened after March 24, 2023, and four years from a crash on or before that date.[5]
If your claim needs none of that work, hiring a lawyer is probably not worth the fee, and a free consultation is a reasonable way to find out. If it needs several of those things, the first two weeks matter most, because the 14-day treatment window, perishable evidence, and the insurance company's request for a recorded statement all arrive in that time. Our claim timeline page lays out the sequence.
Hiring a Florida Accident Lawyer FAQ
- Do I need a lawyer for a minor car accident in Florida?
-
Often no. If the crash caused property damage only, or soreness that fully resolved after one checkup, the claim usually fits inside PIP and a repair estimate, and a contingency fee would not serve you. Get a medical check within 14 days after the crash anyway, because PIP pays no medical benefits if the first treatment comes later. If symptoms persist or return, the answer changes.
- When should I definitely hire a car accident attorney in Florida?
-
When the injury required ongoing treatment or surgery, when fault is disputed, when the at-fault driver carries little or no bodily injury coverage, when a commercial truck, rideshare, or government vehicle is involved, or when someone died. In each of those, the outcome turns on a Florida rule, whether that is the serious injury threshold, the bar on anyone found more than 50 percent at fault, uninsured motorist coverage, or written notice to a government agency.
- How much does a car accident lawyer cost in Florida?
-
A car accident lawyer works on a contingency fee, a percentage of the recovery set in a written agreement before work begins. If there is no recovery, there is no fee. Florida Bar rules limit the percentage, and the agreement must say how case costs are handled. Consultations are free.
- Will hiring a lawyer get me more money?
-
No lawyer can promise that. A lawyer changes the record the insurance company has to evaluate, so that it shows a documented permanent injury, preserved evidence of fault, and every policy that applies, and files the lawsuit on time if the offer does not match that record. In a minor claim that fits inside PIP, a lawyer adds little.
- How long do I have to decide about a lawyer after a Florida crash?
-
The lawsuit deadline is two years for a crash that happened after March 24, 2023, and four years for a crash on or before that date. The first two weeks matter more, because the 14-day PIP treatment rule, camera footage that gets recorded over, and the insurance company's request for a recorded statement all arrive in that time. An early consultation is free and commits you to nothing.
- Can I hire a lawyer after I gave a recorded statement or got an offer?
-
Yes. Nothing stops you from hiring a lawyer after a recorded statement or an offer. A settlement you have signed is final, so the time to ask is before you sign.
- Will I have to go to court if I hire a car accident lawyer?
-
Probably not. Most car accident claims end without a trial. A lawsuit is filed when the insurance company will not pay what the record supports, and Florida judges routinely order mediation before trial.
A Free Call That Tells You Whether Your Crash Needs a Lawyer
If you are not sure which kind of claim you have, ask. Tell us what treatment you have had, what the adjuster has said about fault, and what coverage you know about.
Lawsuit Legal accepts cases selectively and prepares the ones it takes for trial, so the answer may be that you can handle the claim yourself.
Call (888) 713-6653 for a free consultation at any hour, in English or Spanish.
Free Case Evaluation
Let's See If You Have a Case...