Free Case Evaluation
FILL OUT THE FORM BELOW
TO REQUEST YOUR CASE REVIEW
Your Own Alabama Auto Policy May Pay What the Other Driver's Policy Cannot
If the driver who hit you carries too little insurance, your own Alabama auto policy may pay the rest of your damages.
Underinsured motorist coverage comes with every Alabama policy unless the named insured rejected it.
A policy covering more than one vehicle can reach up to three coverages.
Tell your insurer before you settle with the at-fault driver, because settling first can put this claim at risk.
Don Worley, admitted in Alabama, handles these claims against the other driver's carrier and your own at the same time.
Call (888) 713-6653 before you sign a release, for a free review with no fee and no costs unless we recover.
Law reviewed November 5, 2026, against the Code of Alabama and the Alabama Supreme Court's opinions.
Alabama UM and UIM at a Glance
- Included in every Alabama auto policy unless the named insured rejected it
- Up to three coverages under one policy that covers several vehicles
- Notice to your own insurer comes before any settlement with the at-fault driver
What Underinsured Coverage Pays Above a $25,000 Liability Policy
Alabama requires drivers to carry only $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident.[1] A helicopter transport and a surgery can pass that limit before you leave the hospital, and the at-fault driver rarely has savings to collect from. Many have no policy at all. The Insurance Research Council estimated that 16.8 percent of Alabama drivers were uninsured in 2023.[2]
Alabama's statute treats a vehicle as uninsured when the driver's limits are less than the damages you are legally entitled to recover, so underinsured coverage sits inside the same uninsured motorist statute.[3] It is your coverage, paid for with your premiums, and using it for a crash someone else caused is what it is for.
An illustration, using made-up numbers
Your damages are $300,000. The at-fault driver's policy pays its $25,000 limit. Your own policy carries $50,000 of UM coverage on each of two vehicles, so you may reach $100,000 by stacking.
Together that is $125,000, which leaves $175,000 of harm unpaid, and that gap is why we also look for an employer, a vehicle owner, or another responsible party. Your real numbers depend on your policy and your injuries.
The practical step today is to find your declarations page, the summary your insurer sends at each renewal, and every other auto policy in your household. If you cannot find them, your agent or insurer can send copies.
Stacking Up to Three UM Coverages Under Ala. Code § 32-7-23
"...but not to exceed two additional coverages within such contract."
When one policy covers several vehicles, Alabama lets you use the primary coverage plus the coverage on additional vehicles, up to two additional coverages in that contract.[3] A three-car household with $50,000 on each car may be looking at $150,000 rather than $50,000.
A carrier may quote a single limit first, so we read the policy and the declarations page ourselves.
A separate policy in your household raises its own question, because the statute's limit speaks to coverages "within such contract." Bring every policy you can find, including one held by a relative you live with, and let us sort out which ones apply.
The Order of Steps Under Lambert Before You Accept a Settlement
The at-fault driver's insurer may offer its limits quickly and ask for a release. Your own insurer has a right to pursue that driver afterward, called subrogation, and a release can wipe that right out. Lambert v. State Farm sets the order that protects both your settlement and your underinsured claim.[4] No fixed number of days applies, so a day count you hear from an adjuster did not come from this opinion.
| Step | What Happens | What Goes Wrong If It Is Skipped |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Early notice | You tell your own insurer about the claim as soon as you know the other driver's limits may fall short. | Your insurer can argue late notice hurt its position. |
| 2. Notice of the offer | Before you agree to anything, you tell your insurer about the proposed settlement and release. | A release signed first can give your insurer a defense to the underinsured claim. |
| 3. A reasonable time | Your insurer gets a reasonable time to investigate the other driver and the offer. | Pressure from one carrier's deadline can collide with the other carrier's review, so the dates get managed in writing. |
| 4. Your insurer chooses | To keep its right against the other driver, your insurer must advance you an amount equal to the offer before the at-fault driver is released. | If it refuses consent, denies the claim without a good-faith investigation, or delays, it waives that right. |
| 5. The underinsured claim goes on | With the first step closed correctly, you pursue your insurer for the damages above the other driver's limits. | The claim still requires proof of fault and damages, so the evidence work continues. |
If you have an offer in hand, stop there and call. Our Alabama car accident claims page covers the rest of the crash case, and the steps above usually take a letter or two when a lawyer handles them early.
Why Your Own Insurer Can Stay Out of the Trial and Still Be Bound
In Alabama, you can sue the at-fault driver and either join your underinsured carrier in the lawsuit or give it notice. Under Lowe v. Nationwide, a joined carrier can choose within a reasonable time to take part in the trial or to stay out, and if it stays out, the jury never hears about it.[5]
Either way, the Court said the insurer "would be bound by the factfinder's decisions on the issues of liability and damages." You do not have to try the same case twice, and the jury decides your damages without hearing about your own insurance if the carrier opts out.
Your Own Insurer's Defenses, From Contributory Negligence to a Signed Rejection
The coverage pays what you are legally entitled to recover from the other driver, so your insurer can contest fault and damages, though not every defense the driver has, such as the driver's two-year deadline or an immunity. Expect it to look at three things.
- Fault. Contributory negligence can bar an underinsured claim the same way it bars a claim against the driver, and wantonness or subsequent negligence can answer it. Our page on Alabama's fault rule and how it gets answered explains both.
- Your injuries. The adjuster on your own policy may challenge your treatment and your damages as hard as any other adjuster would.
- Whether you have the coverage. The named insured can reject UM coverage, and the Alabama Supreme Court has held that a sole named insured's signed rejection binds everyone else on the policy.[6] Once rejected, coverage need not be provided on renewal unless the named insured requests it in writing.
If your insurer says you have no coverage because of a rejection, ask for the signed form and the policy, and send them to us before you accept that answer.
Rideshare Crashes and the UM Rights Alabama Preserves Under § 32-7C-2
Under Alabama's rideshare statute, the driver or the company must carry $1,000,000 in coverage during a ride, and $50,000 per person and $100,000 per incident while the app is on with no ride.[7] For a rider, the statute preserves uninsured and underinsured rights "as an additional recovery," so a rider's own coverage can still apply when the injuries exceed what the app's policy pays. A rideshare driver should check their own policy, because a personal insurer may exclude this coverage during app time.
How Long You Have to Bring an Alabama Underinsured Claim
Two clocks start on the day of the crash. Your lawsuit against the at-fault driver has to be filed within two years under Ala. Code § 6-2-38. A direct claim against your own insurer for uninsured or underinsured benefits is a contract claim with six years, and the Alabama Supreme Court held in 2024 that it runs from the date of the accident.[8] Settling with the other driver or winning a judgment against that driver does not start it over.
Treat the two years as your working date anyway. Lowe lets you bring your carrier into the suit against the driver, witnesses and video fade, and a separate breach of contract or bad faith claim follows its own timing.
Waiting on one insurer while the two years run is a common way to weaken the claim against both. Give us the crash date and we will put every date on one calendar.