Free Case Evaluation
FILL OUT THE FORM BELOW
TO REQUEST YOUR CASE REVIEW
An ER Can Be Sued for Sending You Home Without the Test
Emergency room malpractice is care in an ER that fell below what a careful emergency team would have given and left the patient worse off.
For many families it was a long wait, a short exam, a diagnosis of something minor, and a trip home.
Hours or days later another hospital found the heart attack, the stroke, the infection, or the internal bleeding.
A bad outcome after an ER visit does not prove malpractice by itself.
You have a claim when the symptoms and vital signs recorded at that first visit called for a test, a specialist, or a hospital bed, and the staff discharged you without it.
The emergency physician, the nurses, the hospital, and the staffing company that employs the doctor can each be responsible.
An emergency room malpractice lawyer at Lawsuit Legal will go over both visits with you at no cost when you call (888) 713-6653.
At-a-Glance: ER Malpractice Lawsuits
- An ER is judged by what a careful emergency team would do with the information it had
- Federal law requires a hospital ER to screen every patient and stabilize an emergency before discharge or transfer
- The triage note, the order times, and the second hospital's chart show what the staff knew and did
- The ER doctor may work for a staffing company, which changes who the lawsuit names
- State deadlines differ, and a claim under the federal ER law must be filed within two years

Do You Have an Emergency Room Case After a Second Hospital's Diagnosis?
You may. A correct diagnosis at a second hospital shows the condition was there to be found, and the open question is whether the first emergency room should have found it with what it knew.
Emergency room negligence is measured against what a reasonably careful emergency physician and nursing staff would have done with the information available at the time. An ER is expected to recognize signs that can mean something life-threatening and to test for those conditions before the patient leaves.
An emergency room case has to prove the four elements of any failure to diagnose claim: the ER took on your care, the care fell below that standard, the lapse caused the injury, and the injury brought real losses.
Some patients arrive with symptoms that gave no fair warning, and some conditions cannot be stopped even when they are caught. We accept an ER case when the records show a gap in the care and a link between that gap and what happened next, and we tell a family plainly when they do not.
Long Waits, Rushed Exams, and Shift Changes Behind Emergency Room Errors
The CDC's National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey counted 155.4 million emergency department visits in the United States in 2022, and 11.5 percent of them ended in a hospital admission.[1] Most visits end with a decision to send the patient home, and a malpractice review looks closely at how that decision was reached.
- Triage and the wait. A patient rated less urgent than the symptoms warranted can wait for hours while the condition worsens, and vital signs taken at the door may never be rechecked.
- An early label that takes hold. After the first doctor writes anxiety, a stomach virus, or a muscle strain, new information gets fitted to that diagnosis and the test that would have disproved it is not ordered.
- The shift change. A patient who arrives late at night may be handed to a new doctor and nurse in the morning, and what the first team learned can be lost in the handoff.
- Sent home without the test. The patient is discharged before the blood work, the scan, or the specialist's opinion that the symptoms called for.
If you waited for hours, or the doctor who signed your discharge never examined you, write that down with the approximate times.
Nine Conditions an Emergency Room Is Expected to Rule Out
Each of these conditions can get worse by the hour and has a recognized set of tests, and each has a page of its own here.
- Heart attack. Women, younger patients, and people with diabetes may have jaw pain, fatigue, or nausea in place of crushing chest pain. A heart attack misdiagnosis claim asks whether the EKG and the troponin blood test were done, repeated, and read correctly.
- Stroke. Patients under 50, and patients whose only symptoms are dizziness or loss of balance, are among those discharged, and a stroke the ER misdiagnosed is measured against the hours in which treatment was still possible.
- Sepsis. An older patient with confusion, weakness, or a fall may have no fever, and a sepsis malpractice claim looks at the hour the blood tests and the antibiotics were ordered.
- Pulmonary embolism. Shortness of breath is blamed on anxiety or asthma when a recent surgery or a long stretch without moving pointed to a pulmonary embolism the ER missed.
- Aortic dissection. Sudden, severe chest or back pain can come from a tear in the aorta, and an aortic dissection mistaken for a heart attack stays hidden when no CT scan is ordered.
- Appendicitis. Young children, pregnant patients, and older adults may not have the textbook symptoms and are discharged with a stomach bug or constipation, which is how a missed appendicitis becomes a rupture.
- Ectopic pregnancy. When no pregnancy test or ultrasound is done for pelvic pain and bleeding, an ectopic pregnancy the ER did not diagnose can rupture and bleed heavily.
- Bacterial meningitis. A young child with fever and irritability may have no stiff neck. A meningitis misdiagnosis claim asks how long the spinal tap and the antibiotics were put off.
- Cancer. A scan done for another reason may show a mass, and a delayed cancer diagnosis can begin with an ER finding nobody followed up after discharge.
What the Triage Note, Order Times, and Second Hospital's Chart Prove
An emergency visit is short and nearly every step in it is time-stamped, so an emergency room malpractice attorney can read the record hour by hour.
- The nurse's triage note gives the arrival time, the complaint in your words, the first vital signs, and the urgency level assigned.
- The later vital signs show whether anyone rechecked an abnormal heart rate, blood pressure, or oxygen level before discharge.
- The orders and results give the time each test was ordered and reported, and a test that was never ordered is missing from the list.
- The EKG tracings and the images are read again by a cardiologist or radiologist we retain.
- The second hospital's chart shows what was found, how far it had advanced, and the treatment it then required. An autopsy report does the same when the patient died.
After enough ER cases, you learn to read the discharge instructions first. They tell you what the team was not considering at the moment they sent the patient home.
The hospital's lawyers will say the doctor had little time, limited information, and a reasonable list of possibilities. The reply is the workup the symptoms called for, and the hospital's own written procedures for chest pain, stroke, and sepsis are evidence of it.
An emergency physician and a specialist in the missed condition do the review. A majority of states require an expert's affidavit or certificate before or along with a malpractice lawsuit, so their opinions are in hand before the case is filed.
The Federal Law That Requires an ER to Examine and Stabilize You
A federal law, the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA), applies to hospitals that take Medicare and offer emergency services. It requires the hospital to give a medical screening examination to anyone who comes to the emergency department asking for care, whether or not the person can pay.[2] If the exam finds an emergency condition, the hospital has to stabilize it or arrange an appropriate transfer, and the law counts a discharge as a transfer.
These situations can violate it:
- You were registered, told the wait was long, and never examined by a doctor or other qualified clinician.
- You were discharged, or moved to another hospital, while the emergency was still unstable.
- You were transferred because of your insurance or your ability to pay.
- You were in active labor and were transferred without being delivered or stabilized.
The federal law does not promise a correct diagnosis. A wrong answer after a real examination is a question for state malpractice law, and one emergency room visit can raise both kinds of claim. A claim under the federal screening, stabilization, and transfer rules is brought against the hospital, so tell your lawyer if you were turned away or sent off before anyone examined you.
Who You Sue When the ER Doctor Works for a Staffing Company
The emergency physician who treated you may not be a hospital employee. Many hospitals contract with an outside staffing company or physician group to run the emergency department, so the doctor who signed your discharge, the company that employs that doctor, and the hospital can be three separate defendants.
A hospital may answer a lawsuit by pointing to that contract, and whether that defense works varies by state. Under a rule called apparent agency, a hospital can be held liable for an independent contractor physician when it presented the emergency room as its own.
The hospital also answers directly for its nurses, its triage, and its staffing. The name on the building is often a trade name, and suing a hospital under its correct legal name starts with its license and corporate filings.
What Losses Decide How Much an ER Malpractice Settlement Is Worth?
An ER malpractice settlement is worth what the missed diagnosis cost you, measured as the difference between the outcome a timely diagnosis would have allowed and the one you have. No figure can be trusted before the records and the medical bills are in hand.
- Medical care. The longer hospital stay, the surgery or intensive care the delay made necessary, and the treatment you will need from here on.
- Income. Pay lost while you recover, and earning ability lost for good.
- Pain and lasting limits. What you went through and what you can no longer do. A number of states put a ceiling on this category in malpractice cases.
When the patient did not survive, the family can file a wrongful death lawsuit based on medical malpractice, and state law may add a claim for what the patient suffered before dying.
A hospital's insurance company and a doctor's malpractice insurance company may each owe part of a settlement. If either one makes an offer in the first weeks, have both charts read before you answer.
Which Deadline Applies to an ER Malpractice Lawsuit, State or Federal?
Both can apply. The state deadline for a malpractice claim against the doctor or the hospital is commonly one to three years. Many states add a last date, counted from the visit, after which no claim can be filed, whenever the mistake came to light. A claim under the federal emergency care law must be filed within two years of the violation, and the statute has no provision that pauses that deadline while a state's presuit steps are completed.
States differ on when the state clock starts. Some count from the ER visit. Others use the discovery rule in the malpractice statute of limitations and start counting on the day the miss was discovered or should have been.
A county or state hospital can come with a written-notice requirement that differs by state. For a federal or VA hospital, the Federal Tort Claims Act applies, and a written claim has to reach the agency within two years. A death adds a separate wrongful death deadline. An emergency visit has an exact date, so an ER malpractice attorney can give you each deadline on the first call.
Protect an ER Malpractice Claim Before You Talk to the Hospital
- Keep every paper from the first visit. The discharge sheet, any prescriptions, and the bill all carry dates and times.
- Request both charts. Ask the first emergency room and the hospital that made the diagnosis for the complete record, including the images and the EKG tracings. Federal law gives a hospital 30 days to answer a request for your own medical records, with one 30-day extension it has to explain in writing.
- Write down the night as you remember it. Note when you arrived, how long you waited, who examined you, and when you went back.
- Let a lawyer answer the hospital. A call from the hospital's risk manager or its insurance company, an offer to waive the bill, or a form to sign can wait until the chart has been read.
An Emergency Room Malpractice Attorney's Fee Comes Out of the Recovery
An emergency room malpractice attorney at this firm charges no fee unless the case brings in money, and the fee percentage appears in the written agreement you receive before you decide to hire us. The firm pays the costs as the case goes, including both hospitals' records and the emergency physician and specialists who review them.
You can talk with us for free, day or night, in English or Spanish. If you or your family member is still in the hospital, we can meet you there.
Emergency Room Malpractice Questions From Patients and Families
- Q: I waited six hours in the ER and left without being seen. Is that my fault?
-
A: Leaving does not end the question. Federal law requires a hospital emergency department to give a screening exam to anyone who comes in asking for care, and the triage note records your vital signs and how long you sat. The hospital's lawyers will point out that you left, and the weight that carries turns on state law and on what you were told about the wait.
- Q: Do I sue the ER doctor, the hospital, or both?
-
A: Often both, and sometimes a staffing company as well. The doctor answers for the exam and the discharge, the hospital for its nurses and its triage, and each state has its own rule on whether a hospital answers for a contractor doctor. We work out who employed whom from the chart, the hospital's license, and the bills you received.
- Q: Does an urgent care clinic count as an emergency room?
-
A: A malpractice claim against an urgent care clinic is judged the same way, by what a careful provider in that setting would have done with your symptoms, which can include sending you straight to a hospital. The federal screening law is written for hospital emergency departments, so it may not reach a clinic that is not part of a hospital.
- Q: A second hospital made the diagnosis. Do I need its records too?
-
A: Yes. The first chart shows what the emergency room knew and did. The second shows what the condition was, how far it had progressed, and what treatment it then took, and the claim is measured by the distance between the two.
- Q: Can our family bring an emergency room malpractice claim after a death?
-
A: Yes. When a patient dies after being sent home, a wrongful death claim can be brought, and the state decides who is allowed to file. In states that require a personal representative, we can help your family start the court process that appoints one. Ask for the autopsy report if there was one, because it can establish what the emergency room missed.
An ER Malpractice Lawyer Can Compare the First Visit With the Second
You went to an emergency room because something was wrong, you were sent home, and another hospital found it, or you lost a husband, wife, or parent before a second hospital could.
Lawsuit Legal puts the two charts side by side with an emergency physician and tells you what the first hospital knew and what it should have done about it.
Clients of this firm have recovered more than $100 million, and we prepare an accepted case for trial against both the hospital and the staffing company.
The review is free. Call (888) 713-6653 whenever you are able, or send the name of the hospital and the date of the visit through the form.
Free Case Evaluation
FILL OUT THE FORM BELOW
TO REQUEST YOUR CASE REVIEW