Free Case Evaluation
FILL OUT THE FORM BELOW
TO REQUEST YOUR CASE REVIEW
What an Independent Medical Examination Actually Is and How to Survive It
An Independent Medical Examination (IME) is a medical exam ordered by the insurance carrier or defense, performed by a doctor the carrier selects and pays. The "independent" in the name is the carrier's framing. Plaintiffs' attorneys typically call it what it is: a Defense Medical Examination (DME).
The IME report almost always concludes that your injuries are less serious than your treating physicians say, that you reached maximum medical improvement (MMI) sooner than your records suggest, and that some portion of your symptoms relate to pre-existing conditions rather than the accident.
The IME is routine. The IME is predictable. The IME is contestable.
This page covers the two distinct types of IME (litigation IME and PIP IME), what to expect at the exam itself, what to do before, during, and after, and how the IME report is challenged in negotiation and at trial.
Talk to a personal injury attorney before you attend any IME. The exam is documentary evidence the carrier will use against you. Preparation matters.
At-a-Glance: Surviving an Independent Medical Examination
- Two types of IME exist: litigation IME (after suit is filed, under Rule 35 or state equivalent) and first-party PIP IME (under Fla. Stat. § 627.736(7) and similar no-fault statutes)
- The IME doctor is selected and paid by the carrier. Frequent defense witnesses appear in IME reports across thousands of cases for the same carriers
- The exam is typically brief (15 to 60 minutes) and focused on records review plus a limited physical examination
- The IME report almost always concludes injuries are less severe, MMI was reached sooner, and pre-existing conditions caused symptoms
- You can bring an observer or have the exam recorded in many jurisdictions. Check your state's rules and ask your attorney before the exam
- Failure to attend a properly noticed IME can result in sanctions including dismissal of claims, exclusion of evidence, or loss of PIP benefits
- An experienced attorney challenges the IME report through cross-examination, treating physician testimony, the doctor's frequent-defense-witness history, and the AMA Guides to Permanent Impairment
Litigation IME vs. First-Party PIP IME
Two distinct types of IME exist in personal injury practice. They run on different rules.
- Litigation IME (Defense Medical Examination). After a personal injury lawsuit is filed, the defense can request a court-ordered medical examination of the plaintiff under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 35 or the equivalent state rule. The exam requires a court order or stipulation, must be performed by a doctor with appropriate qualifications, and is limited to the medical conditions in controversy.
- First-Party PIP IME. Florida no-fault law under Fla. Stat. § 627.736(7), and similar provisions in other no-fault states, allows the PIP carrier to require an exam as a condition of continued PIP benefits. Refusal to attend without good cause can terminate PIP coverage entirely. The exam is conducted by a carrier-selected doctor, with limited procedural protections compared to a litigation IME.
- Workers' Compensation IME. Workers' comp carriers can order independent medical exams under state comp statutes. Procedures vary widely by state. Refusal to attend can suspend wage-loss and medical benefits.
The procedural differences matter. A litigation IME comes with stronger plaintiff protections (right to bring an observer in many jurisdictions, right to record, right to receive the report, ability to challenge the doctor's selection). A first-party PIP IME comes with fewer procedural protections but the same evidentiary stakes.
What Actually Happens at an IME
The exam itself is typically shorter than people expect.
- Records review (often before the exam). The IME doctor reviews your medical records, the police report, and any imaging. This work happens at the doctor's office, not in your presence
- History intake. The doctor asks how the accident happened, what injuries you suffered, what symptoms you have, and what treatment you have received. Answer truthfully and concisely. Do not volunteer information beyond the question
- Physical examination. Limited orthopedic or neurological exam focused on the conditions in controversy. Range of motion, reflexes, strength testing, palpation. Typically 15 to 30 minutes
- No treatment. The IME doctor is not your doctor. They will not prescribe medication, order imaging, or provide treatment recommendations. Do not expect medical advice from the exam
- The report. Typically issued within a few weeks of the exam. The report contains the doctor's opinions on diagnosis, causation, MMI, permanent impairment rating, and need for future care
Behave with the IME doctor as you would with any treating physician: polite, cooperative, factual. The exam is documentary evidence. Conduct that the doctor characterizes as exaggerated, evasive, or hostile becomes part of the report.
Before, During, and After the Exam
What an experienced personal injury attorney coaches the client to do at each stage.
- Before. Review your own medical records and the accident facts so you can describe them consistently. Confirm with your attorney whether you can bring an observer or record the exam in your jurisdiction. Plan to arrive on time and dress appropriately. Bring a list of your current medications and treating providers
- During. Answer questions truthfully and concisely. Describe pain accurately (do not exaggerate, do not minimize). Demonstrate effort on physical tests but do not push past pain. If a movement causes pain, say so. If a question is unclear, ask for clarification before answering
- After. Note the time the exam started and ended, what tests were performed, who else was present, and what the doctor said. A short written summary made the same day is the strongest record of what actually happened. Provide it to your attorney. Request a copy of the report when it is issued
Do not discuss the exam with the carrier directly afterward. The IME report goes to the adjuster. The adjuster's interpretation is the carrier's, not yours.
How an IME Report Is Challenged
The IME report is one piece of evidence among many. It is not the final word on your medical condition. Effective challenges to an IME report include:
- Treating physician testimony. Your treating doctors examined you over weeks or months. The IME doctor saw you for 30 minutes. Treating physician opinions on diagnosis, causation, and permanence carry substantial evidentiary weight
- Frequent defense witness history. Many IME doctors testify almost exclusively for the defense. Discovery into the doctor's IME practice (number of IMEs performed annually, percentage of opinions favoring the defense, fees charged) exposes bias
- Internal inconsistencies. IME reports often contain inconsistencies with the doctor's own findings, with the underlying medical records, or with the AMA Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment. Cross-examination on those inconsistencies undermines the report
- Failure to consider all records. If the IME doctor reviewed only selected records or missed key diagnostic studies, the basis for the opinions is undermined
- Eggshell plaintiff doctrine. Where the IME doctor attributes symptoms to pre-existing conditions, the eggshell rule reframes the analysis: aggravation of pre-existing conditions is fully compensable
The IME report rarely wins the case for the defense by itself. It anchors the carrier's negotiating position and provides defense expert testimony at trial. Both are challengeable with proper preparation and treating physician documentation.
Talk to an Attorney Before Your IME. Preparation Is the Difference.
The IME is documentary evidence the carrier will use against you. The doctor's report goes to the adjuster, the defense lawyer, and (if the case proceeds) to the jury. What you say at the exam, how you describe your pain, how you move during the physical, and what you do not volunteer all become part of the record.
Our personal injury lawyers prepare clients for IMEs daily. We review the carrier's selected doctor, run the doctor's IME history, coach you on what to expect and how to handle the questions, and explain what you can and cannot do under your jurisdiction's rules. After the exam, we get the report, identify weaknesses, and develop the cross-examination and treating physician testimony that contests it.
The consultation is free. You pay nothing unless we recover compensation for you.
Call 888-713-6653 before your IME appointment. The earlier we are involved, the stronger the preparation.
Free Case Evaluation
FILL OUT THE FORM BELOW
TO REQUEST YOUR CASE REVIEW