Structured Settlement or Lump Sum After a Catastrophic Injury

Free Case Evaluation


FILL OUT THE FORM BELOW
TO REQUEST YOUR CASE REVIEW

    A Structured Settlement Trades Flexibility for Fixed, Tax-Free Payments for Years

    A lump sum pays your injury settlement in one check, and a structured settlement pays it as a schedule of payments over a set number of years or for life.

    For a structure, the defendant's insurance company uses part of the settlement to buy an annuity from a life insurance company, and the annuity makes the payments.

    When the settlement is for a physical injury, federal tax law keeps the money out of your income whether it arrives in one check or as periodic payments.

    Once the schedule is set, you cannot speed the payments up, delay them, or change the amounts.

    structured settlement attorney representation quote

    A lump sum leaves you free to pay off debt, buy a home, or invest, and responsible for making the money last.

    A settlement can also be split, with part paid at signing and the rest structured.

    Make the choice before you sign the release, because a settlement check that has already been paid cannot be turned into a structure.

    • Payments for a physical injury are tax-free under IRC 104(a)(2), in one check or over time
    • Structured payments cannot be sped up, delayed, raised, or lowered once the settlement is signed
    • In nearly every state, selling future payments needs a judge's approval, and buyers pay a discount
    • CMS's $25,000 and $250,000 Medicare set-aside review thresholds are workers' compensation rules
    • No fee unless we recover; your fee agreement shows how the fee is figured on a structure
    structured settlement representation

    How a Structured Settlement Works

    The defendant, or the insurance company paying for the defendant, hands the duty to make your future payments to an assignment company, which buys an annuity from a life insurance company to fund them. You receive the payments on the schedule written into the settlement.

    Section 130 of the Internal Revenue Code makes that hand-off work. It lets the assignment company take on the payments without paying tax on the money it receives to fund them, so long as the payments are fixed in amount and timing and cannot be sped up, delayed, raised, or lowered by you.[1] Congress added it in a law signed in January 1983.

    The schedule is built around the future losses your claim projects: monthly payments for attendant care, larger payments in the years equipment wears out, a lump payment every five or ten years for a surgery your doctor expects, and payments timed for retirement. The dates and amounts come from the life care plan in a catastrophic case, so the structure is usually designed once the plan is finished.

    The payments depend on the life insurance company behind the annuity. Before you agree, ask the settlement planner which company will issue it and how its financial strength is rated, and keep that answer with your settlement papers.

    structured settlement annuity payments

    How Structured Settlement Payments and a Lump Sum Are Taxed

    For a physical injury, the starting point is the same either way. Internal Revenue Code § 104(a)(2) keeps damages received on account of personal physical injuries or physical sickness out of your income, "whether as lump sums or as periodic payments," and that covers economic and non-economic damages alike.[2]

    Each structured payment is tax-free in full, including the part of later payments that reflects growth over the years. A lump sum is tax-free when you receive it, but once you invest it, the interest, dividends, and gains it earns are taxed to you like any other investment income.

    That tax difference is one side of the comparison. The other side is the rate the annuity pays, which is fixed when it is bought, and a payment that stays the same every year buys less as prices rise. A financial adviser can run both sides for your settlement before you choose.

    Punitive damages and interest on a judgment are taxed in either form, as the rules on which parts of an injury settlement are taxable explain.

    Do You Need a Medicare Set-Aside in an Injury Settlement?

    You might, if you are on Medicare or expect to be soon and part of the settlement pays for future injury care. Medicare is a secondary payer under 42 U.S.C. § 1395y(b)(2), so it is not supposed to pay for care a settlement already covers, and a Medicare Set-Aside (MSA) is money from the settlement kept apart to pay for that care.

    The figures most often quoted come from workers' compensation. CMS reviews a proposed workers' comp set-aside when a Medicare beneficiary settles for more than $25,000, or when a person reasonably expected to enroll in Medicare within 30 months settles for more than $250,000, and even there CMS recommends review without requiring it.[3] Set-asides are routine in workers' comp settlements; for an injury claim against the person who hurt you, Medicare's policy is less clear, and whether one is used depends on your Medicare status and how much of the settlement is meant for future care.

    A set-aside can be funded with one payment or with an annuity. Repaying Medicare for treatment it covered before the settlement is a separate step, handled before the money is paid out under the rules for paying back Medicare and Medicaid from a settlement.

    How Fixed Payments Hold Up Against Overspending, Creditors, and Inflation

    A structure locks the money into a schedule, which protects it in some ways and limits you in others.


    • Spending. Money that has not been paid yet cannot be spent early or lent to someone who never repays it, which protects a settlement meant to last decades.
    • Creditors and divorce. Whether a creditor, a bankruptcy court, or a divorce court can reach structured payments is decided by state law, and the answer differs from state to state. Ask how your state treats them before you count on that protection.
    • SSI and Medicaid. Structured payments count as income for SSI and Medicaid, the same as a lump sum does. A special needs trust after an injury can receive the payments instead, so they do not count against you.
    • A long life. Payments made for life continue however long you live, while a lump sum can run out.
    • Inflation. A payment that stays the same each year loses buying power as prices rise, so ask whether the schedule can build in a yearly increase.

    The cost is flexibility. If a large expense comes up that the schedule did not plan for, such as a new house or a family medical emergency, the payments cannot be moved forward.

     

     

    Selling Structured Settlement Payments Later Takes a Judge's Approval

    If you structure your settlement and later need cash, you can sell some or all of the future payments to a buyer, often called a factoring company, but only at a discount, so you receive less than the payments are worth.

    Nearly every state has a structured settlement protection act that requires a judge to approve the sale. Federal law adds its own check: a buyer who closes the deal without a qualifying court order owes a tax of 40 percent of the discount, and the order must find that the sale is in your best interest, taking into account the welfare and support of your dependents.[4] Your state's act sets the court, the notice, and the paperwork.

    Because of the discount, selling payments is a costly way to raise money that could have been taken as cash at settlement. If you expect to need a large sum in the first few years, ask for it as part of the settlement instead.

    When to Take a Structured Settlement, a Lump Sum, or Both

    The answer turns on your age, your care needs, your other money, and any benefits you receive, and it starts from a lifetime cost figure that will hold up, the work of defending a lifetime cost projection.


    A Structure Tends to Fit When

    • You are young and your doctors expect care for decades
    • Your life care plan includes years of attendant care or equipment that has to be replaced
    • You want the money paced so it cannot be spent or lent before it is needed
    • You are settling for a child, and the payments can be timed to start at 18; in many states a judge approves a child's settlement and decides how the money is held
    • You receive SSI or Medicaid, and the payments can go into a special needs trust
    • Your tax bracket is high enough that untaxed growth adds up over a long schedule

    A Lump Sum Tends to Fit When

    • You are older and the schedule would be short
    • You already manage investments and want control of the money
    • You face large costs right away, such as a mortgage, debts, or an accessible home
    • The settlement is small enough that a schedule adds little
    • Your life care plan puts most of the cost in the first few years

    Splitting the Settlement Between Cash and Payments

    A settlement does not have to be all one or the other. Part can be paid in cash at signing for debts, home changes, and a reserve, and the rest structured to cover attendant care, equipment replacement, and the long years of upkeep that a paralysis case brings.

    Before you decide, ask a financial adviser to compare the options, and if you receive public benefits, bring in a special needs trust attorney as well. Once the release is signed, the schedule cannot be changed.

    How the Lawyer's Fee and the Settlement Planner Are Paid on a Structure

    Your personal injury lawyer is paid from the recovery. When part of the money is paid over years, the written fee agreement governs how the fee is figured, so ask to see that calculation on the settlement statement before you sign it.

    We are paid only if the claim recovers money, and we advance the costs of the case while it is open.

    A settlement planner designs the payment schedule and arranges the annuity. Ask the planner, in writing, who pays them and how, and whether they were brought in by your side or the defendant's. We are not financial advisers, so the investment side of the choice belongs with an adviser you pick.

    Questions About Structured Settlement Payments and Lump Sums

    Q:    Are structured settlement payments taxable?

    A:    Not when the settlement is for a physical injury or physical sickness. Each payment is kept out of your income under IRC § 104(a)(2), including the growth built into later payments. Punitive damages and interest on a judgment are taxable however they are paid.

    Q:    Can I change my mind after agreeing to a structured settlement?

    A:    Not once the release is signed and the annuity is bought. Federal tax rules require that you cannot speed up, delay, raise, or lower the payments. The only way to reach the money sooner is to sell payments, with a judge's approval and at a discount.

    Q:    Can I sell my structured settlement payments?

    A:    Yes, in nearly every state, with a judge's approval under the state's structured settlement protection act. The buyer pays less than the payments are worth, and the order approving the sale has to find it is in your best interest with your dependents in mind. Plan for cash you know you will need at settlement instead.

    Q:    Who pays for the structured settlement annuity?

    A:    The defendant or its insurance company buys the annuity with settlement money, through an assignment company, so you pay nothing extra to set it up. Its cost comes out of the settlement total.

    Q:    What happens to structured settlement payments if I die?

    A:    That is set when the schedule is written. Payments guaranteed for a set period go to the person you name if you die during that period, and life-only payments stop at death.

    Q:    Do I need a Medicare set-aside for an injury settlement?

    A:    Possibly, if you are on Medicare or will be soon and part of the settlement pays for future injury care. The $25,000 and $250,000 review thresholds CMS publishes apply to workers' compensation set-asides, and for other injury settlements Medicare's policy is less clear. A set-aside can be funded with one payment or with an annuity.

    Q:    Will a structured settlement protect my SSI and Medicaid?

    A:    Not by itself, because structured payments count as income for SSI and Medicaid. A first-party special needs trust can receive the payments, or a lump sum, so the money does not count against you.

    Q:    Can a smaller injury settlement be structured?

    A:    Federal tax law sets no minimum, though the annuity company may, so ask the planner. For a smaller settlement, weigh whether paced payments are worth giving up access to the money, since the schedule cannot be changed once it is signed.

    Free Review of a Structured Settlement Offer, at Home or in the Hospital

    structured settlement decision deadline

    When a catastrophic injury claim is close to settling and the payout is still open, the choice between one check and decades of payments ends the day the release is signed.

    Lawsuit Legal can check a proposed payment schedule against your life care plan and your benefits before you commit to it, and you owe no fee unless the claim recovers money.

    If you are still in the hospital or recovering at home, a lawyer can meet you there.

    With the settlement offer or the proposed payment schedule in front of you, call (888) 713-6653 to talk it through at no charge.

     

     

     

     

     

    Free Case Evaluation


    FILL OUT THE FORM BELOW
    TO REQUEST YOUR CASE REVIEW

      External Resources
      Legal Representation

      "Speak with our catastrophic injury attorneys for a free, confidential review of your settlement structure. Past results vary based on the unique facts of each case."

      Find out more >>