Free Case Evaluation
Let's See If You Have a Case...
A Fatal Crash Settlement Pays the Family's Losses Within Policy Limits
When another driver's carelessness caused the crash that took someone from your family, the law lets your family be paid for what the death has cost it.
That covers the pay and the care the person gave, the funeral and final medical bills, and in most states their companionship and guidance as well.
In our experience, these settlements have run from the low six figures to eight figures, and the facts of each death decide where a family's claim falls.
The other driver's insurance company pays only up to its policy limit, and when that limit is low, your family's own underinsured motorist coverage or another defendant's policy may add to it.
State law decides who may settle for the family and sets a filing deadline that may run out sooner than an injury claim's would.
The funeral comes first; a release that arrives with an early check can be set aside, unsigned, for a lawyer to read.
Whenever your family wants to talk, a lawyer will talk the claim through with you free of charge at (888) 713-6653, with no fee unless money comes in for your family.
At-a-Glance: Settling the Claim When a Crash Takes a Life
- Your state's wrongful death statute names who may settle, often the estate's personal representative, sometimes a spouse or child
- Bodily injury minimums run as low as $15,000 per person, and most Florida drivers need carry none
- Underinsured motorist coverage your loved one carried can pay once the at-fault driver's limit is exhausted
- New York allows two years from the death, one fewer than for an injury; Tennessee one year from the injury
- The firm is paid from a recovery or not at all, and it pays the economist and reconstruction expert meanwhile
Who Can Accept a Fatal Car Accident Settlement on the Family's Behalf
The person who can accept a settlement, and sign the release that ends the claim, is the one your state's wrongful death statute names.
In many states it falls to the estate's personal representative, someone the probate court appoints to act for every relative the statute protects. Other states let close relatives, such as a spouse, child, or parent, bring the claim in their own name. Since each state hands out the authority to bring a death claim its own way, your family's own statute should be read before anyone acts for the others.
Where your state requires that appointment before a claim can go forward, we help the family get the probate case started, and you can call us before it has begun.
Knowing who holds that authority tells the family who should take the adjuster's calls now and who will sign when the time comes.
The Wrongful Death and Survival Claims Inside a Car Accident Death Settlement
A settlement after a fatal crash usually resolves two claims at once, and in most states they cover different losses.
Through the wrongful death claim, the family is paid for its own losses. The survival claim is the injury claim your loved one would have had, continued by the estate after the death. Tennessee is the exception, with one action that covers both. Whether a loss belongs to the survival action or the wrongful death claim also decides who receives that part of the money.
- The income your loved one would have earned. An economist projects the pay and benefits of the remaining working years and reduces them to present value, as with other future damages. This is usually the largest financial part of the claim, and it turns on age, work, and earnings history.
- The help they gave at home. Child care, repairs, driving, and caring for a relative each have a replacement cost, and an early offer often leaves them out.
- Their companionship and guidance. In most states a spouse, children, and sometimes parents are paid for the relationship itself. State caps reach this part of the claim more than any other.
- The funeral, the burial, and the final medical bills. These are proven with the itemized bills.
- Your loved one's suffering before death. Where the person survived the crash for hours or days, the survival claim can recover that pain, along with the medical costs and lost pay of that time.
- Punitive damages. In some states, an added award when the death came from reckless or intentional conduct, such as driving drunk.[1]
What a family can recover changes at the state line. New York pays a family only for losses measured in money, such as lost support and household services, and a proposed law that would have added grief and lost companionship, the Grieving Families Act, did not survive the governor's veto and is not law. In Alabama a death claim pays punitive damages and nothing else.
A handful of states cap the companionship part of a death claim. In Kansas it stops at $250,000 plus costs, and in Wisconsin at $350,000 for an adult and $500,000 for a minor, while the constitutions of Kentucky and Wyoming forbid such caps. Your state's row in the damage cap table for every state shows its figure, and the wrongful death damages each state allows show which categories it pays.
The funeral bill, the hospital bills, and the last pay stubs and tax returns are how each of these losses is proven, so they are worth keeping together.
Insurance Layers Beyond a State-Minimum Policy After a Fatal Crash
When a family's losses outrun the at-fault driver's policy, as they can after a death, the policy limit becomes the practical ceiling on what that driver's insurance company pays. The survival claim and anyone else hurt in the crash usually draw on the same limits, which is part of valuing a death claim from a motor vehicle crash.
The At-Fault Driver's Policy
State minimums are low. Louisiana and Pennsylvania require only $15,000 of bodily injury coverage per person, New York requires $50,000 when a crash causes a death, and in Florida most drivers are not required to buy it at all; each state's floor is listed among the car insurance minimums by state. A judgment above the limit becomes the driver's own debt, and it may go unpaid.
Your Family's Own Underinsured Motorist Coverage
UIM, short for underinsured motorist coverage, on your loved one's policy, and under some policies on the policy of a relative in the same home, can pay once the at-fault driver's limit runs out. Its partner, uninsured motorist coverage (UM), pays when the at-fault driver carried no insurance at all, or drove off and was never identified, as after a fatal hit-and-run. Tennessee does not let a family stack the UM limits of two vehicles or policies.
Accepting the at-fault driver's limit without first notifying your own insurance company can cost the family its underinsured claim under many policies.
Employers, Trucking Companies, and Others Who Share the Blame
If the driver was working, the employer's commercial policy can apply, and federal rules require interstate trucking companies to carry liability coverage far above passenger-car minimums. A crash involving a commercial truck, a delivery van, or a rideshare driver at work usually brings far more coverage than a crash between two private cars.
The owner of a borrowed car, an umbrella policy, or a bar that kept pouring for a drunk driver whose crash took a life, where state law allows that claim, can each add another source. A crash with no second car can still trace to a failed part or a poorly kept road, which is why a single-vehicle fatal accident is investigated before anyone accepts that the driver alone was at fault.
Each added policy raises the most the claim can collect, which is why the demand to the insurance company waits until the search is done.
How Much Do Fatal Car Accident Settlements Pay a Family?
The amount follows what the death takes from your family over the years ahead, limited by the insurance behind everyone responsible.
The low end of the range we have seen came where little insurance stood behind the driver, and the high end where a person with many working years ahead was killed by a well-insured commercial defendant. A claim backed by nothing more than a state-minimum policy can recover less than that low end.
Within that span, these facts move the figure:
- Your loved one's age, earnings, and the working years the crash took
- Who depended on that income, care, and guidance, and for how long
- How plainly the evidence puts the crash on the other driver, and any share of blame put on your loved one, which your state's fault rule may subtract or use to bar the claim
- Which losses your state allows a family to claim, including any cap
- Every insurance policy that applies, and its limit
Because these facts differ from one death to the next, two families who lost someone in similar crashes can settle far apart. The same facts set the value of any wrongful death settlement, whatever caused the death.
Anyone who guarantees a specific dollar figure on a wrongful death case is not being honest with you. What we can do is prepare the case so that it's valued correctly and provide the strong legal representation needed to go after every penny.
Is a Car Accident Death Lawsuit Due Sooner Than an Injury Lawsuit?
In many states it is, because a death claim runs on the wrongful death statute's own deadline, and some of those deadlines start on a different day than the death.
New York allows two years from the death, a year less than for an injury lawsuit there. Nebraska and Utah allow two years against four for an injury, and North Dakota two against six. Tennessee's single year runs from the injury, so days in the hospital before the death use up part of it, and no state allows less.
Other states count from other dates. Kentucky's year starts when the estate's representative is appointed, with two years after the death as the outside limit. Louisiana gives whichever is longer of one year from the death and two from the injury. Florida and Texas allow two years from the death, and South Carolina three. In Georgia, a criminal prosecution of the driver for the crash puts the deadline on hold. The wrongful death column of the filing deadlines in every state gives the rest.
If a city or state agency may share the blame, ask early about its notice rule, since some states want written notice within months of the crash. Your loved one's own auto policy sets separate notice terms for an underinsured claim.
If your state's probate court has to name a representative before a lawsuit can be filed, that appointment has to fit inside the same deadline.
Paying for the Funeral and the Lawyer Before a Fatal Crash Settlement
The funeral home and the hospital send their bills on their own schedule, and a settlement rarely comes in time to pay them.
The auto policy your loved one carried may include personal injury protection, known as PIP, or medical payments coverage, known as MedPay, and either one can pay part of the final hospital bill before fault is decided. If the death resulted from a crime, drunk driving or a hit-and-run for example, your state's fund for crime victims may cover some funeral costs, usually after insurance has paid what it will. Keep every bill and receipt, since the claim is proven with them.
If the other driver's adjuster phones, your family can refuse a recorded statement and pass along the lawyer's name instead. The first weeks after a fatal car accident also bring the crash report, the vehicles, and the death certificate, and those can be taken one at a time.
Hiring us costs your family nothing at the start. Our fee is a percentage, set out in the agreement your family signs, of whatever the claim recovers, and when nothing is recovered the family pays no fee. We pay for the economist who projects lost earnings, the accident reconstructionist, and the records while the case is underway, and the agreement explains how those costs are handled at its close.
The fee works the same way on a death claim as on the other personal injury cases we take. We take on death claims selectively and get each one ready for a jury, though most families' claims settle without a trial.
Dividing, Taxing, and Timing a Fatal Car Accident Settlement
- Q: How is a fatal car accident settlement divided among family members?
-
A: The wrongful death statute in your state controls the division. Many put a spouse and children first, with parents or other dependents after them, and a will usually cannot change that order. Money from a survival claim generally passes through the estate instead. When a child shares in the money, some states have a judge review the division, and how wrongful death money is shared varies enough that your state's statute should be read first.
- Q: Does our family owe income tax on a car accident death settlement?
-
A: Usually not on the compensatory part. Federal tax law excludes damages paid on account of a physical injury, and compensatory damages for a death generally fall under that rule. Punitive damages, and any interest a court adds to a judgment, are taxed, except that punitive damages in a death case are excluded in a state whose law allows only punitive damages for a death, which in practice is Alabama. How the settlement is divided among its categories can change the result, so a tax professional should see the agreement before it is signed.
- Q: How long does a fatal car accident claim take to settle?
-
A: It depends on the case. A claim with clear fault and one adequately insured driver can resolve within months, while disputed fault, several defendants, a commercial insurance company, or a criminal case running alongside can stretch it out, especially if a lawsuit heads toward trial. Settling before the lost income has an economist's projection behind it, and before every policy is found, tends to leave money out of the family's recovery.
- Q: Should our family wait for the driver's criminal case to end before settling?
-
A: Not for the claim's sake. A civil claim for the death needs no conviction, and in most states its deadline keeps running during the prosecution, though Georgia pauses its clock. In many states a guilty plea or a conviction can be offered as proof of the driver's fault, and the investigation done for the prosecution can help the claim. Whether to settle before the criminal case ends depends on whether every policy and every loss is already known.
- Q: The insurance company offered to pay for the funeral. Should we accept?
-
A: Read the papers that come with the money before accepting it. A funeral payment offered with a release attached may close the family's whole claim, and in many states only the person the wrongful death statute names can sign for the family. A lawyer can read the offer and tell you whether it asks the family to give anything up.
Counsel for a Family Weighing an Insurance Offer After a Fatal Crash
A family that has lost someone in a car accident can be handed a release and a check before the funeral is over.
Lawsuit Legal reads any offer your family receives against every policy that may pay, and where your state calls for an estate representative, we help your family apply for that appointment.
The number is (888) 713-6653. The first consultation is free, and it can take place in Spanish or in your home.
The person who calls does not need to be the one who will act for the estate.
Free Case Evaluation
Let's See If You Have a Case...