Free Case Evaluation
FILL OUT THE FORM BELOW
TO REQUEST YOUR CASE REVIEW
Bad Faith Can Make an Insurance Company Liable Above the Policy Limits
If your insurance company is stalling, underpaying, or refusing a claim it should pay, Florida law may let you hold it to account for more than the claim itself.
That is a bad faith claim, and it can run against your own insurance company or, after a judgment, against the company that insures the person who injured you.
An insurance company that could and should have settled within the policy limits, and did not, can end up owing the full judgment.
Carelessness alone is not bad faith, and since 2023 a liability insurance company that pays within 90 days of a documented claim cannot be sued for it.
Before you can sue, a civil remedy notice must be filed with the state, and the insurance company then has 60 days to pay or correct the problem.
What you keep and send now, while the claim is still open, is the record a bad faith case is later decided on.
At-a-Glance: Florida Bad Faith After HB 837
- Bad faith can make an insurance company liable for damages above the policy limits
- Negligence alone is not bad faith under Fla. Stat. § 624.155(5)
- Paying the limits or the demand within 90 days of a documented claim bars a liability bad faith claim
- A civil remedy notice and a 60-day cure period come before any statutory bad faith lawsuit
- You and your lawyer owe a duty of good faith in demands, deadlines, and information

Can You Sue an Insurance Company for Bad Faith in Florida?
"Not attempting in good faith to settle claims when, under all the circumstances, it could and should have done so, had it acted fairly and honestly toward its insured and with due regard for her or his interests" Fla. Stat. § 624.155(1)(b)1.
Yes. Florida gives any person damaged by an insurance company's bad faith a civil action, and the test is whether the company failed to attempt in good faith to settle a claim when, under all the circumstances, it could and should have done so.[1]
For you, that can look like a company that refuses a reasonable chance to settle within the policy limits, sits on a claim it has the documents to pay, or will not explain a denial. A slow file or an adjuster's mistake is different. Under the 2023 amendments known as HB 837, mere negligence alone is insufficient, so the claim file has to show that the company failed to act fairly and honestly toward its insured.
The same amendments put a duty on you. You, your lawyer, and the insured person each owe a duty of good faith in furnishing information, making demands, setting deadlines, and attempting to settle, and a jury may reduce the bad faith damages if that duty is breached. A demand with an impossible deadline, or one sent with the medical records held back, hurts your own case.
While the claim is open, keep every letter and email, write down the date and the name on each phone call, and put your demand in writing with the records that support it and a reasonable date for an answer.
Can You Sue the Other Driver's Insurance Company Directly?
Not at first. If someone else injured you, Florida does not let you sue that person's liability insurance company until you have a settlement or a verdict against the person it insures.[2] The lawsuit names the at-fault driver, and the driver's insurance company defends it and pays what the policy covers.
A bad faith claim against that company comes later, and only if events take a particular course. The company refuses to settle your claim within its policy limits when it could and should have. The case goes to a verdict above those limits, and the company's own customer is left owing the difference. The bad faith claim then seeks that excess from the insurance company.
A claim against your own insurance company is a direct claim. In injury cases that is most often an uninsured motorist claim, because Florida does not require most drivers to carry bodily injury liability coverage and your own policy may be the only coverage for your injuries. If your company does not try in good faith to settle that claim, the same statute applies, and the damages can include your total damages above the uninsured motorist limits (Fla. Stat. § 627.727(9)). Our page on uninsured driver claims in Florida explains how those claims are supposed to work, and our Florida car accident lawyers page covers the crash claim underneath.
The Civil Remedy Notice and Its 60-Day Cure Period Under § 624.155
Before you can file a statutory bad faith lawsuit, the Florida Department of Financial Services and the insurance company must be given 60 days' written notice of the violation. That notice is the civil remedy notice. It is filed on the department's form, and the department sends it to the insurance company.
The notice has to state five things:
- The statutory provision the insurance company allegedly violated, with its specific language.
- The facts and circumstances giving rise to the violation.
- The name of any individual involved in the violation.
- The specific policy language that is relevant to the violation, if any.
- A statement that the notice is given to perfect the right to pursue the civil remedy.
The insurance company then has 60 days from receiving the notice to pay the damages or correct the circumstances that gave rise to the violation. If it does, no bad faith lawsuit can follow. For you a cure means the claim is paid, which is what you wanted when you filed it.
The 60-day notice was in the statute before the 2023 amendments, and it applies to a claim against your own insurance company as well as to a liability claim. Because the statute lists what the notice must contain, a notice that leaves out one of those items invites a challenge, and any bad faith litigation that follows starts from what the notice said.
The 90-Day Window to Pay the Policy Limits or the Amount Demanded
The 2023 amendments gave liability insurance companies a way to close off a bad faith claim. If the company tenders the policy limits, or the amount you demanded if that is lower, within 90 days after it receives actual notice of your claim with sufficient evidence to support the amount, no bad faith action can be brought on that claim.
For you, the 90 days begin only when the company has a documented claim in hand. Sending the medical records, the bills, and the proof of lost income with your demand is what starts the clock.
If the company misses the 90 days, two things follow. Any applicable statute of limitations is extended by 90 days. And in a later bad faith case, the jury is not told that the 90-day window existed or that a timely payment would have barred the claim.
This window covers liability claims. It does not apply to a claim on your own PIP or homeowners policy.
How a Florida Bad Faith Lawsuit Recovers Money Above the Policy Limits
In most injury claims, what you can collect stops at the policy limits. Bad faith is how a claim can exceed them.
Suppose the at-fault driver's policy limit is $25,000, the insurance company refuses a documented demand for that amount, and a jury later awards $100,000. The driver owes the $75,000 above the limit, and a bad faith claim seeks that excess from the insurance company.
The statute says the damages recoverable are those that are a reasonably foreseeable result of the violation, and that they may include an award or judgment that exceeds the policy limits. If the insurance company loses the bad faith case at trial or on appeal, it also owes court costs and reasonable attorney fees. Punitive damages are available only when the conduct was a general business practice and was willful, wanton, and malicious, or in reckless disregard of the insured's rights.
None of this pauses your injury claim. The underlying lawsuit still has to be filed within two years for a negligence claim that accrued after March 24, 2023, or within four years for one that accrued on or before that date.
Florida Bad Faith Insurance FAQ
- What is insurance bad faith in Florida?
-
It is an insurance company's failure to attempt in good faith to settle a claim when, under all the circumstances, it could and should have done so, acting fairly and honestly toward its insured. Negligence alone is not enough under the 2023 amendments to § 624.155. An insurance company found in bad faith can owe damages above the policy limits.
- Can I recover more than the policy limits in Florida?
-
A bad faith claim is how a claim can exceed the policy limits. If the insurance company wrongly refused to settle within the limits and a verdict later exceeds them, the bad faith action seeks the excess from the company. It depends on a record showing that the company had a documented chance to settle and refused.
- What is the 90-day rule in Florida bad faith cases?
-
It is a safe harbor for liability insurance companies, added by HB 837 in 2023. A company that pays the policy limits, or the amount demanded if lower, within 90 days after receiving actual notice of a claim with sufficient supporting evidence cannot be sued for bad faith on that claim. If the company does not pay within the 90 days, a later jury is not told that the 90-day window existed, and any applicable statute of limitations is extended 90 days.
- Do I have to file a civil remedy notice before suing an insurance company for bad faith?
-
For a claim under § 624.155, yes. A civil remedy notice stating the statute violated, the facts, the people involved, and any relevant policy language must be filed with the Department of Financial Services, which sends it to the insurance company. The company then has 60 days to pay the damages or correct the violation, and if it does, no lawsuit can follow.
- What does a bad faith attorney charge to review a denied claim?
-
Nothing for the review. If we take the case, we work on a contingency fee, a percentage set in the written agreement you sign, and there is no fee unless we recover money for you.
Send the Insurance Company's Denial Letter to a Bad Faith Attorney
Months of waiting on a claim, or a denial letter that does not match what your policy says, leaves you asking whether this is slow service or bad faith. You do not have to answer that alone.
Lawsuit Legal reads the claim the way a court would, starting with what the insurance company was sent, when it was sent, and what the company did next. We prepare the injury claim underneath for trial from the start, so the record is complete if the company still refuses to pay.
The consultation is free. Call (888) 713-6653 with the denial letter, your demand, and the company's replies in front of you. If nothing was sent to you in writing, the dates of your phone calls are enough to begin.
Free Case Evaluation
FILL OUT THE FORM BELOW
TO REQUEST YOUR CASE REVIEW